We’re Not Little Babies Anymore!
On Researching and Teaching Black German Adoption History
By Dr. Rosemarie Peña · Founder and President, BGHRA · November 17, 2026
LanguageRescue NarrativesImages and the ClassroomScholarly Responsibility
We are real people whose lives extend far beyond the childhood photographs through which we are so often introduced. We grew up. We became scholars, parents, community builders, and interpreters of our own histories. Research and teaching about Black German adoption must take our adult lives, knowledge, and authority seriously.
The Words Through Which We Are Named
I find the continued use of “Brown Babies” as an uncomplicated description of us deeply troubling. For me, it is a violent and infantilizing label. Terms such as “occupation children,” “war babies,” “Mischling,” and “Mischlingskinder” also require explicit critical framing whenever they are encountered in historical sources. Quoting a source does not release a researcher from responsibility for the language carried into a title, abstract, exhibition, or classroom. Historical language can be examined without becoming the language through which we are named today. Use people’s chosen terms and explain why any harmful historical wording must be reproduced.
Whose Story Does a Rescue Narrative Tell?
I am also concerned by celebratory accounts of Mabel Grammer that leave adoptees’ perspectives and the consequences of adoption insufficiently examined. Her activities should be studied critically alongside the experiences of the people whose lives were affected. A story organized around rescue or the achievements of an intermediary cannot, by itself, tell us what adoption meant across an adoptee’s lifetime. We need room for different experiences, difficult questions, and accounts that complicate the familiar narrative.
You Do Not Know Who Is in Your Classroom
“You do not know everyone’s history in your classroom.”
The same responsibility applies to photographs, colonial imagery, racist caricatures, and disparaging descriptions. These may depict someone’s mother, father, sibling, or another relative. They may also depict a person sitting in the room. You do not know everyone’s history in your classroom. Announcing that an image illustrates racism does not settle whether showing it is necessary or how its display may affect the people present.
Before reproducing such material, ask what specific question it helps answer, whose perspective accompanies it, and whether the lesson can be taught through a less exposing example or a careful description. Where display is necessary, provide context before showing it, explain its production and circulation, and limit repetition. Give students advance notice and a meaningful alternative way to engage. Do not ask those affected to identify themselves, explain their pain, or educate the room.
Archival availability is not a substitute for ethical judgment. An image credit cannot tell us whether a person’s life has been represented responsibly. Researchers should seek the input of identifiable living adoptees where practicable, take their wishes seriously, and explain the limits of what can be known when consultation is not possible. An unidentified person still deserves dignity.
Engage with the Scholarship and the People
Scholars entering this field should engage seriously with existing Black German and adoptee scholarship, including my work and Silke Hackenesch’s. Citation should change how a question is framed, how evidence is read, and whose interpretation carries weight. Engagement permits disagreement; it requires recognizing and addressing the knowledge already produced.
The exclusion of adoption and the Black German Heritage and Research Association (BGHRA) from the prevailing narratives and scholarly corpus of Black German studies is intellectually violent. It erases adoptees as historical subjects and knowledge producers and disregards BGHRA’s sustained work in research, preservation, education, and community building. Work that reproduces this exclusion becomes complicit in the misunderstanding of the globally situated community that constitutes the Black German diaspora. Our histories, relationships, and contributions extend across national borders. Adoption and the knowledge produced by adoptees must be integral to how this field understands Black German life and belonging.
I welcome new scholarship and thoughtful collaboration. I ask researchers, educators, curators, filmmakers, authors, and novelists to approach us as people capable of interpreting our own lives. Our images and histories carry relationships and consequences into the present. We must have a meaningful place in deciding how they are told.
Continue With Scholarly Activism
This statement puts the responsibilities described in Scholarly Activism: The Peña Framework into practice through naming, images, teaching, and adoptee authority. Read the framework to explore community knowledge, historical accountability, and reparative practice.
Suggested Citation
Peña, Rosemarie. 2026. “We’re Not Little Babies Anymore!” Black German Heritage & Research Association. November 17.
